Curse of Knowledge

Three simple words can help us understand the problems many advisors face as they attempt to engage their clients toward retirement success: Curse of Knowledge.[1] Advisors know so much about their own world that they forget the context of those they seek their help and end up not being helpful to anyone. The good news is that becoming aware of this disconnect can help advisors take steps to address and overcome the challenge.

Coined by Colin Camerer et al.,[2] the phrase describes how people who have significant knowledge assume that the people to whom they are speaking (1) have more knowledge than they actually do, and (2) understand what is being communicated when in reality they do not.

To better understand the concept, play this simple game, which replicates a study performed by Stanford University graduate students. Make a list of familiar songs most everyone knows and then form a group with two other people. Share the list with Person A, asking him or her to tap out the rhythm of each song. Have Person B write down the name of the song they think was tapped out. Then ask Person A to guess how many songs Person B identified. Person A typically overestimates the number of songs that Person B guessed correctly. This is a simple example of the Curse of Knowledge.

Advisors immerse themselves in financial data by reading trade journals, pursuing continuing education, answering clients’ questions, running illustrations, interacting with colleagues, and more. They happily live in the world of financial information that would give many other people a migraine. This wealth of information brings many benefits, but it can become a curse if the advisor fails to spend time thinking about the client’s perspective.

Consider the average person’s engagement with financial information. Most 401(k) participants don’t even use the plan portal to manage their accounts, and while defined benefit plans were designed to make it easy for people to understand their benefits, most don’t. These two facts should help financial advisors realize that most clients are not ready to engage in the financial analysis that advisors live in each day.

With this in mind, I’ve identified three questions advisors can ask themselves to improve their message and better engage current and prospective clients:

  1. How meaningful is this information to my client? Or, what is the felt need of my client? Financial advisors may think all aspects of financial information are meaningful, but they should focus on the perceived relevance for their client. In other words, advisors need to think from the client’s perspective. In reality, most of a financial advisor’s data simply is not perceived as meaningful by most clients.
  2. What is concrete for my client? Each subject falls on a continuum between abstract and concrete. The more ready a client is for retirement (or the closer the client is to retirement), the more retirement subjects become concrete for the client.
  3. What is actionable for my client? The more actionable a topic is, the more engaging the education will be, and vice versa.

To optimize the education process, a topic must be meaningful, concrete, and actionable to the greatest possible extent. Let’s consider how these three criteria play out in a few examples:

  1. Asset Allocation
    Discussions about asset allocation are meaningful for clients with retirement savings but almost meaningless for someone without much savings. The subject as a whole is probably near the midpoint on the continuum from abstract to concrete, but isn’t very actionable besides filling out an asset allocation questionnaire. Speaking with a group about asset allocation would likely be very abstract.
  2. Debt Reduction
    Discussions about debt reduction are meaningful to those who have debt, and when done right those conversations can be concrete, especially in a one-on-one meeting. However, in a group meeting, that same topic could easily become generic and abstract.
  3. Retirement Planning
    Discussions about retirement planning are meaningful for almost everyone and may be concrete if they are presented with clear facts. (In contrast, a Monte Carlo analysis would make the topic more abstract.) The topic certainly becomes actionable by focusing on any retirement planning deficits your clients may have.

Your analysis of these three examples may differ from mine—and that’s fine. What’s important is to analyze topics from the perspective of your audience—not the perspective of someone with financial expertise. Adopting this approach will help you improve your engagement with current and potential clients.


Blog Link References:

[1] I heard this phrase in my recent podcast interview with Jonathon Schultheiss, Managing Director of Strategic Retirement Partners. Click here to listen to that podcast.

[2] Camerer, Colin & Loewenstein, George & Weber, Martin. (1989). The Curse of Knowledge in Economic Settings: An Experimental Analysis. Journal of Political Economy. 97. 1232-54. 10.1086/261651.

Better Participant Outcomes: The Solution

Advisor-driven education uses a three-pronged engagement process to connect personally with participants: Connect Internalize Initiate.

Five Ways to Boost Participant Engagement

Much of the conversation about 401(k) participation and whether participants are adequately saving for retirement centers on the plan sponsor. Plan design and administration play a big part in plan success. However, there is still much that an individual plan advisor can do to help improve...

The Bucket Strategy – What It Is, and What It Can Do for You

The bucket strategy provides an opportunity to capitalize on longer-term market growth in the earlier years of retirement while easing the fear of risk and the tendency to overreact to market fluctuations.

Calculating Federal Deposit and Redeposit Service

One of the purposes of The Retirement Analysis Kit (TRAK) and TRAK-Online software is to reduce the complexity of financial planning – a solution to help advisors with the many complex calculations and illustrations while producing results that clients can easily understand. Nowhere is this more helpful than working with pension plans, which bring their complications.

Tips for Working with Public-Sector Employees

Are you looking for new clients? How would you like to tap into an underserved group of over 23 million people? Your next client may be someone you already know like your mail carrier, your local firefighter, or your child’s teacher. Public-sector employees are one of the largest groups of...

Don’t Settle for Auto Enrollment—Push for Higher Contributions

RetireReady Solutions believes education is the key to navigating the challenges of guiding clients through retirement years, helping young Americans establish a secure financial future, and increasing AUM for advisors through higher contributions.

Navigating the Ripple Effects of Student Debt

The ever-growing burden of student debt is a source of alarm for many Americans. Here are a few tips to help you support clients who are struggling to balance student debt and retirement savings.